On the Wing #10: National Geographic Wing Syndrome

The dreaded NGWS as seen on a Northern Gannet.
As you can probably guess from the title, I have a bone to pick with the National Geographic Field Guide System. Recently while plodding around the internet looking for a way to get more species on my life list, I noticed an advert for Seven Seas Whaling Trips out of Gloucester, MA. While I'm thrilled that they've been seeing several pelagic species (Sooty (Puffinus griseus) and Great Shearwaters (P. gravis) mainly), my eye was drawn to a particular picture on the Northern Gannet (Morus bassanus) page. It was an image of a Northern Gannet doing something I'd never thought I'd see a bird do ever in the wild. It was making "the pose". "The pose" I'm referring to is National Geographic Wing Syndrome (NGWS for short) and can be seen in the picture on the right. Of course, one could argue it's just the positioning of the bird at a slight angle as to give the suggestion of the wing bending in an unnatural way, but in doing so just makes the bird look weird.

It's unfortunate I pick up on these things, but as a birder, attention to detail is key and if something is out of place, it's either broken or something's deliberately missing. In the case of NGWS, I first noticed it as a child looking at the third or fourth edition of their field guide on North American birds. This feature is especially noticeable in the waterfowl section and is used to try and attract the readers eye to the speculums seen on the puddle ducks. As opposed to showing the upper and underside for comparison, the artist had to go and make it look weird by curling one wing over the top to tease the viewer into looking at this distorted wing! As far as I can tell, no other field guide has managed to do this. Peterson sticks to the simple template image, while Sibley is a little artsy, but is quite standard in his work as well. The photo guides don't come into play because unless you're deliberately going for shots like the one above, you'd go mad quicker trying to get one than just simply photographing the creature at hand.

I just wanted to do a quick blog entry to get this thought out of my head. These little things needle away at you, but you can't explain it to nonbirders as well, because in the end, they just don't understand.

Update: I have been fishing through my own copy of "The National Geographic Society: Field Guide to the Birds of North America" and it appears that the small rant I've constructed above has been undermined by a severe lack of evidence. However, there are examples of NGWS in the book on the following page numbers (pg. 58, 66, 124, and 214)and I apologize for the exaggerated claims made by the rant above. However, my general irritation with said phenomena is still withstanding.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Nature Note #201: Blue Cranes and Long Whites

Image
There is a small pond on the Trinity Center property I walk past everyday and is exceptionally buggy. Even when you are covered head to toe with 25% DEET bug spray, it seems to have no effect. The other day, as I rounded a bend, something lifted off from the top of a gnarled cedar. A tall bird croaked with agitation, flying away on long wings and extending a snaking neck. The bird in question was a great blue heron ( Ardea herodias ), a charismatic and recognizable marsh bird that is familiar to most people. Despite their common presence around wetlands, ponds, and rivers, I have heard them mistaken for another tall marsh bird, and are sometimes called "blue cranes". Immature great blue seen near Bogue Sound in Pine Knoll Shores, NC. Photo by me. Bird misidentification isn't a new issue. Even as naturalists and budding ornithologists like John James Audubon and Alexander Wilson were traveling the country identifying the birds they could; even they used colloquial n...
Read more

Nature Note #122: Adventures in Pennsylvania: (Non-Native) Space Invaders

Image
As the first week at the Outdoor School* ended and the weekend arrived, I thought about what to write about this week. I had made it a goal to learn some common night-singing insect calls by visiting the Songs of Insects website and while I haven't done that yet, Sunday isn't over either. After returning from Giant to get some milk, I went for a walk to find some subjects for this weeks post. I decided to settle on three invasive plants that have appeared on the property over the summer. We were introduced to the first during orientation while walking from the group challenge field over the Pennypack Creek that runs through the property. The plant's huge leaves were what surprised me the most, as well as seeming so tropically out of place with the mid-Atlantic environment they were now living in. Initially we were stumped as to their identity, but after one of my bosses did some research, he determined that they were Empress or Princess Trees. Their scientific name is Pa...
Read more

Nature Note #187: Devil Down Head

Image
I love old nicknames for birds. Whether they are folk names, sportsmans colloquialisms, or even names from other languages, learning how other groups of people identify certain animals and plants is always an interesting journey through the history of human culture and wildlife identification. The title of this post refers to an old folk name for a common yard and feeder bird, the nuthatch. Here in the northeast, we have two species of nuthatches; the white-breasted ( Sitta carolinensis ) and the red-breasted ( S. canadensis ). White-breasted nuthatch Red-breasted nuthatch Both species are perhaps best known for their tree-scaling ability that would make any free climber jealous of their skills. Many ornithologists have been equally amazed by the skills of the nuthatch. The economic ornithologist, Edward Howe Forbush noted in his Birds of Massachusetts that: "They seem to have taken lessons of the squirrel which runs down the tree headfirst,  stretching out his hi...
Read more